STATE POLLING DATA:
PRO: ______%
CON: ______%
IDK: ______%
IMPORTANCE: ____
INTRODUCTION:
Community
service and commitment to our country have long been essential staples of
American society and culture. John F.
Kennedy during his 1961 inaugural stated "Ask not what your country can do
for you; ask what you can do for your country." With the ending of the military draft in 1973
(with only male registration since that time), there is no institutional requirement
for young American citizens to serve their country. Service for the country would provide an
individual educational experience, provide vital assistance to many government
programs, and provide a justifiable and earned stipend for further education. It can also serve as a way for young
immigrants to quickly become part of the
WHAT THIS BILL WOULD DO:
The
Department of Health and Human Services would set up a registration and
placement system for all 18 to 26 year old
PRO ARGUMENTS:
This is a great opportunity to provide life and work experience to young men and women right out of High School (or college if deferred service accepted). This experience would develop well-rounded citizens imbued with the spirit of community service. This young labor pool would also serve to significantly enhance or improve the quality of service that government could provide, hence improving our quality of life and standard of living. This service would also provide young people with a chance to evaluate their life goals and choose an appropriate education and training program post-service that will support their goals. This program will also serve to provide a rapid gateway to Citizenship for immigrants who legally enter the country.
CON ARGUMENTS:
This will be an expensive entitlement program for young people. Hidden in the cost will be the provision of virtual life long health care. The screening and deferment program will be subject to abuse as many try to "get out" of service. The requirement for mandatory service could lead to a division of Americans into those who served and those whom did not inflicting an injurious stigma upon non-servers that could cause discrimination. It could also increase the amount of people who try to enter the country without a Visa.
CONCLUSION: